1 - 10 of 2742 (0.88 seconds)
workmen. She further contended that
in any case shockingly disproportionate punishment in the
light of the nature of the misconduct ... ample jurisdiction in appropriate cases to set aside such
disproportionate punishment in the light of the charges held
proved against
Supreme Court of India
employee, so as to amount to the shockingly
disproportionate punishment."
So far as the aforesaid Clause (g) is concerned ... found by the Court to be
a shockingly disproportionate punishment. It is not possible to agree
with the contention
Bombay High Court
service of the employee so as to amount shockingly disproportionate
punishment. That the Labour Court concluded that the unfair labour ... employee, so as to amount to shockingly disproportionate
punishment".
In my view, it is not possible to accept the extreme
Bombay High Court
employee, so as to amount to a shockingly
disproportionate punishment."
Item 1 (g) of Schedule IV refers, therefore, only ... restricted in
character, limiting itself to shockingly disproportionate punishment in
the case of misconduct of a minor or technical character
Bombay High Court
imposition of unduly
harsh, severe, unconscionable or shockingly disproportionate
punishment; (iv) whether the employer has paid or Offered ... management, is held to be severe, extreme and shockingly
disproportionate punishment to the charges levelled against the
petitioner, which warranted
Madras High Court
management to impose such a
harsh and shockingly disproportionate punishment, has rejected the
approval petition. The learned counsel would further ... finds that the action of management in awarding shockingly
disproportionate punishment was not bona fide.
The submission of the learned
Madras High Court
awarding the punishment of dismissal.
(g) The punishment is harsh and disproportionate to the charges made
against the petitioner ... India, 1984 Lab IC (NOC) 73 (Bom.).]
Punishment not to be disproportionate to the gravity of the charge
established
Allahabad High Court
Union of India and Ors., to contend that
the punishment disproportionate to the offence and shocking to
conscience amounts ... that fundamental
freedom is affected in the case of disproportionate punishment.
2.5. He then contended that certificate issued
Calcutta High Court
case by the petitioner employer is "not a shockingly disproportionate
punishment". In that context, Mr. Cama pointed out Schedule ... employee, so as to amount to a shockingly
disproportionate punishment. Therefore, it is contended by Mr. Cama
that
Bombay High Court
Punishment not to be disproportionate to the gravity of the charge
established.
(B) Ordinarily the court or tribunal cannot interfere ... Supreme Court has
considered the punishment to be harsh and disproportionate to the
gravity of the charge and modified
Allahabad High Court
Get new documents for this query in your RSS feed reader -